This etch was thought to be a Paden City etch but recent scholarship by Bill Walker is changing that opinion. The etch has also been found on what is believed to be Imperial Molly and Beaumont, and an identical silver overlay has been found on German and Czech glass company products leading Mr. Walker to decide that the etching was probably done by a decorating company. However, the patent for the supposed Beaumont piece was actually assigned to the Anchor Mfg. Company.